Hands-on Activity: Switcheroo
Contributed by: Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder

 SummaryIn this hands-on activity, students construct a simple switch and determine what objects and what types of materials can be used to close a switch in a circuit and light a light bulb.
 Engineering Connection Relating science and/or math concept(s) to engineering Engineers have a fundamental understanding of electrical circuits and the function of insulators and conductors. The first true plastic material used for the housing of electrical switches and electrical outlets was an insulator called Bakelite, invented in 1909 by engineer and chemist Leo Hendrik Baekeland. Today, material and chemical engineers continue to design and develop specialty materials that can be used for many different types of electrical device parts, both for conducting and insulating.

 Contents
 Grade Level: 4 (3-5) Group Size: 3 Time Required: 20 minutes Activity Dependency :None Expendable Cost Per Group Keywords: My Rating: Avg Rating: Not Yet Rated.Teacher Experiences  |  Share your experience!

Related Curriculum :

 subject areas curricular units lessons

Educational Standards :

• f. Select an appropriate tool and unit for measuring length, weight, and capacity (Grade 4) [2009] ...more
• b. Show that electricity in circuits requires a complete loop through which current can pass (Grade 4) [2009] ...more
• c. Describe the energy transformation that takes place in electrical circuits where light, heat, sound, and magnetic effects are produced (Grade 4) [2009] ...more
•   International Technology and Engineering Educators Association: Technology
• E. Models are used to communicate and test design ideas and processes. (Grades 3 - 5) [2000] ...more
• D. Tools, machines, products, and systems use energy in order to do work. (Grades 3 - 5) [2000] ...more
•   Next Generation Science Standards: Science
• Generate and compare multiple possible solutions to a problem based on how well each is likely to meet the criteria and constraints of the problem. (Grades 3 - 5) [2013] ...more
• Make observations and measurements to identify materials based on their properties. (Grade 5) [2013] ...more

After this activity, students should be able to:
• Explain the function of a switch in an electrical circuit.
• Understand that an object's material properties determine whether it will make a good switch.
• Explain why engineers must have a fundamental understanding of electrical circuits and the function of insulators and conductors.

Each group needs:
• Switcheroo Worksheet, one per student
• 1 D-cell battery
• 1 large rubber band
• 1 #40 miniature bulb, such as a flashlight bulb (available at electronics surplus stores, such as RadioShack; see http://www.radioshack.com/product/index.jsp?productId=2102809)
• 1 miniature light bulb holder
• 2 small nails (or metal thumbtacks, but not push pins)
• a small piece of wood (or a small piece of thick cardboard)
• 2 ft (30.5 cm) insulated wire (gauge AWG 22, available at hardware stores), cut into three pieces of equal length (8 in)
For the entire class to use:
• an assortment of conducting/insulating objects: paper clips, aluminum foil, nails, coins, various gauges of insulated wire, keys, rubber bands, erasers, plastic rulers, cloth, pipe cleaners, etc.
• wire strippers or sandpaper (to remove insulation at wire ends)
• hammer
Note: Many of the materials required for this lab can be reused in numerous other electricity activities. When the batteries wear out, dispose of them at a hazardous waste disposal site.

Ask students if they have ever used a light switch to turn on a light in a room. Have you ever tried to figure out what is happening when you flip a switch on the wall and the light turns on? How does an electrical switch work? What would happen to the light in your room if you left the switch on? (Possible answers: The bulb would burn out, I would be scolded for leaving the light on, I would waste electricity.)
A switch can create either an open circuit or a closed circuit, depending on its position (on or off). Inform the students that in today's activity they will build their own electrical switches and determine which materials make the best switches.
 Figure 1 A basic manufactured wall switch showing insulator materials used for the on/off toggle and housing, and conductive materials used to carry the electrical current.copyright
Explain to students that material engineers create new types of materials for specific purposes, for example, so that they are strong and can survive very high temperatures. Material engineers work with chemical engineers to design and develop materials that can be used for many different types of switches and socket plugs. The switches and electric socket plugs used in our homes and schools are connected to copper wires that carry electrical current and can get very hot, so for our safety, the housing and parts that touch the wires of switches and plugs must be made of insulators developed by material and chemical engineers. An early material used for the housing of electrical switches and plugs was a plastic insulator called Bakelite. It is considered the first, true plastic and was invented in 1909 by engineer and chemist Leo Hendrik Baekeland.

Background — Switches

The purpose of an electrical switch is to regulate current (the flow of electric charge) in a circuit. Most switches are used to open and close a circuit. Light and appliance power switches are examples of the most basic type of switch. When the switch is in the "on" position, a conductor inside the device closes the circuit so electrical charge can move through it, powering the light bulb or appliance (see Figure 2). When the switch is moved to the "off" position the circuit is broken, and no current flows.
 Figure 2. A basic switch setup, showing the conductor in the switch not connecting the two switch terminals, thus the switch is open, and the light bulb is not lit.copyright

Background — Dimmers and Multi-Position Switches

Dimmer switches and multi-position switches regulate the amount of current in a circuit. Dimmer switches are used on lamps and light fixtures. When a dimmer switch is first turned to the "on" position, the circuit is closed and a small amount of current is present in the circuit, lighting the bulb dimly. As you move the dimmer switch, the resistance of the lamp circuit is decreased, thus increasing the current in the circuit, causing the bulb to shine brighter and brighter. An electrical component called a variable resistor, or rheostat, is connected to the dimmer switch knob to change the resistance in the circuit within some range; the volume knob on a stereo works in a similar way. Multi-position switches work in almost the same way as dimmer switches except that the resistance of the circuit can only be changed between a few set values. Multi-position switches are typically used on appliances with motors or fans.

Before the Activity

• Assemble an assortment of materials for the students to use in making switches. Include materials that will not work as switches (insulators), too.

With the Students

Remind students that electricity flows more easily through some objects than others. The materials that electrons can move through are called conductors. The atoms in a conductor have loosely-attached electrons, so a negative charge buildup pushes electrons through the material. Electrons in metals are loosely attached to the atom, so metals are conductors. If the electrons in a material are tightly attached to the atoms and cannot be forced to move from one atom to another, no electricity flows. These materials are called insulators. Some examples of insulators include rock, wood, plastic, glass, cloth, and air.
1. Hand out a Switcheroo Worksheet to each student. Have the students look at and list all the objects available to make switches. Next to each object listed write "yes" if you think it will make a good switch and "no" if you think it will not.
2. Working in teams and using wire strippers or sand paper, have students remove 1/2 in (1.3 cm) of the insulation from the ends of three pieces of wire to ensure a good connection.
3. Use one piece of wire to connect the positive terminal of the D-cell battery to one of the terminals on the light bulb holder. Use rubber bands and masking tape to attach the wire to the positive terminal of the battery.
4. Use a second piece of wire to connect the negative terminal of the D-cell battery to a small nail (or thumbtack). Use rubber bands and masking tape to attach the wire to the negative terminal of the battery.
5. Tightly wrap one of the bare ends of the third piece of wire around a small nail (or thumbtack). Connect the other end of this wire to the opposite, unused light bulb terminal.
6. To complete the setup, hammer the nails (or tacks) into the wood (or cardboard) so they are 1–2 cm apart (see Figure 3).
 Figure 3. The basic switch setup using two nails and a small block of wood.copyright
1. Have students choose two to three objects with which to construct their team's switches.
2. To create and test a switch, lay a test object across the two nails (or thumbtacks) to complete (close) the circuit (see Figure 4). If the light bulb lights up, the circuit is closed, current flows and the object works as a switch (conductor). If the bulb does not light up, the object does not make a good switch.
 Figure 4. An operating switch using a nail (left) and an inoperable switch using a piece of cloth (right).copyright
1. After a team has tested and found a switch that they believe is reliable, have them demonstrate its operation. To be a good switch, it should be able to open and close the circuit three times in a row.
2. Have students complete the Switcheroo Worksheet.

• Advise students to be careful when handling the sharp nails (or thumbtacks).
• Warn students to be cautious when hammering nails into blocks of wood.

Some coins may not be very good conductors due to their metal combination. If a coin is being used to close the circuit, make sure that it will conduct electricity at this low voltage. For example, some nickels are not good conductors.

Pre-Activity Assessment

Prediction: Have students use the Switcheroo Worksheet to list all the objects provided to make a switch. Next to each object, have them write "good switch" if they think it will make a good switch and "no" if it will not.

Activity Embedded Assessment

Worksheet: Have students use the Switcheroo Worksheet throughout the activity to record test results, observations and conclusion.

Post-Activity Assessment

Worksheet Analysis: Review the various objects that the class used to make switches. Have students compare their initial predictions about each test object with their test results, as recorded on the worksheets. Have each group make a short presentation to the class explaining which objects they chose and why, and demonstrating their best switch. Discuss with the class which materials made good switches.
Discussion Questions: Solicit, integrate, and summarize student responses:
• What properties are required in a good switch? (Possible answers: The ability to complete the circuit so the current can flow to light the bulb, a conductor, a metal.)
• How might an engineer determine if a material would make a good switch? (Answer: An engineer would test a material to determine whether it was a conductor. Conductors make good switches.)
• How might an engineer determine if a material would make a safe housing for a switch? (Answer: An engineer would find, test and/or develop materials that would keep the current in the switch from leaking from the circuit and/or harming a person using it. An insulator would make a good switch housing.)

Have students estimate the cost of the different materials or objects they used to make switches. Which materials or objects do they think make the best and least expensive switches?
Bring a dimmer switch and a multi-position switch to class (available at hardware stores). Let the students examine the switches. Have the students find picture of devices that use variable resistors and rheostats.

Leo Baekeland, Scientists & Thinkers, Time Online, accessed April 2004. http://inventors.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http://www.pathfinder.com/time/time100/scientist/profile/baekeland.html

Contributors

Xochitl Zamora Thompson, Sabre Duren, Joe Friedrichsen, Daria Kotys-Schwartz, Malinda Schaefer Zarske, Denise W. Carlson