Teach Engineering Home Page
Keyword Search
Edu. Standards Search
Advanced Search Tips to improve your search
Login |Your Account


Lesson: Superhydrophobicity — The Lotus Effect

Contributed by: NSF CAREER Award and RET Program, Mechanical Engineering and Material Science, Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University
Two photos: (left) Lotus flower with many white petals. (right) A water droplet on a lotus leaf looks like a perfectly round, clear bead.
The lotus flower is a symbol of purity in many Asian cultures. The plant is "self-cleaning" due to its superhydrophobic leaves.

Summary

Students are introduced to superhydrophobic surfaces and the "lotus effect." Water spilled on a superhydrophobic surface does not wet the surface, but simply rolls off. Additionally, as water moves across the superhydrophobic surface, it picks up and carries away any foreign material, such as dust or dirt. Students learn how plants create and use superhydrophobic surfaces in nature and how engineers have created human-made products that mimic the properties of these natural surfaces. They also learn about the tendency of all superhydrophobic surfaces to develop water droplets that do not roll off the surface but become "pinned" under certain conditions, such as water droplets formed from condensation. They see how the introduction of mechanical energy can "unpin" these water droplets and restore the desirable properties of the superhydrophobic surface.

Engineering Connection

Relating science and/or math concept(s) to engineering

Inspired by nature, the self-cleaning superhydrophobic products being engineered today are destined to become important and novel products in our everyday lives. Some products include: coatings that reduce the water drag on boats and protect surfaces and equipment exposed to fresh or salt water, building materials that remain clean with little maintenance and are better protected from wear from the elements, and textiles that are resistant to staining and/or remain dry when submerged in water.

Contents

  1. Learning Objectives
  2. Introduction/Motivation
  3. Background
  4. Associated Activities
  5. Assessment
  6. References

Grade Level: 12 (10-12) Lessons in this Unit: 1234
Time Required: 30 minutes
Lesson Dependency :Surface Tension, Capillarity — Measuring Surface Tension, Wetting and Contact Angle
Keywords: biomimicry, chemical engineering, contact angle, hydrophilic, hydrophobic, lotus, lotus effect, self-cleaning, surface tension, superhydrophobic, water, water droplet, water-repellent, wetting
My Rating:
Avg Rating:
Not Yet Rated.
Teacher Experiences  |  Share your experience!

Related Curriculum

subject areas Life Science
Biology
Physical Science
Chemistry
Physics
curricular units Surface Tension
activities Exploring the Lotus Effect

Educational Standards :    

Does this curriculum meet my state's standards?       

Learning Objectives (Return to Contents)

After this lesson, students should be able to:
  • Describe situations in which a superhydrophobic lotus-effect surface would be useful.
  • Explain the difference between Cassie-Baxter and Wenzel wetting and how it applies to superhydrophobic surfaces.
  • Demonstrate the transition between Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter wetting states.

Introduction/Motivation (Return to Contents)

(In advance, prepare the capability to:
  1. Show students a 24-second video of water on a lotus leaf
  2. Show students the Figure 1 photos, either by projector or a printout to pass around
  3. Conduct a demonstration using a lotus leaf*, water, mud, sand, water container, and fish tank
  4. Show the class a few Internet videos using a computer and projector
*Note about the lotus leaf: In addition to lotus leaves, the leaves of the following plants also demonstrate superhydrophobicity: broccoli, Brussels sprout, cabbage, collard greens, kale, taro (elephant's ear), tulip, turnip greens and water lily. All leaves should be fresh, or have been kept refrigerated in a plastic bag since being cut. Alternately, purchase dried lotus leaves from an Asian grocery. Keep in mind that the oils from your hands will eventually destroy the effect. Wear lab gloves if you plan to use the same leaf for multiple classes.)
Two photos: (left) Two hugging Muddy Buddy racers — women covered in mud with bike helmets and pinned-on race numbers. (right) A muddy car.
Figure 1. Using self-cleaning products, you may be able to avoid stained clothing and dirty cars.
(Begin the lesson by showing students the 24-second "Water on Lotus Leaf" video, and leading a brainstorming session, as described in the Assessment section.)
(Show the class the photographs in Figure 1. While they are being projected or passed around, ask students questions about concepts learned in previous surface tension lessons.)
Looking at these photographs, do you think dry dirt would stick as well to the clothing and car as the mud does? Why do you think the mud sticks better? What do you think we can change to make the mud less likely to stick? (Let students think about their answers and make their best educated guesses.)
(Take any everyday object and place it into a container of water and then pull it out. Make the point to students that the object is "wet" — point out the water drops on it.) Why does the water stick?
(Take a lotus leaf [or other leaf] and ask a student to touch along the edge of the lotus leaf.) How does it feel? (The lotus leaf feels smooth; description will vary with other plants).
What will happen when I pour water onto this leaf? (Tilt the leaf towards the class. Pour water onto the leaf and allow it to run into a container.) What is happening to the water? (The water forms beads and runs off the surface without appearing to stick to the leaf at all. You may want to introduce the ideas of water-repellant surfaces and surface structure of the lotus leaf.)
(Immerse a lotus leaf into a fish tank of water. The surface of the plant appears silvery). What causes the silver color while the lotus leaf is under water? (Air trapped by the surface structure. The water is not being allowed to touch the leaf directly.)
What will happen when I pull it out of the water? (When you pull the leaf out it should be perfectly dry. If possible, have a few students come up and try it for themselves.)
(Sprinkle dirt or sand onto the lotus leaf.) What do you think will happen if I pour water on top of the dirt? Will the mud/wet sand stick to the leaf? (Listen to student predictions.)
(Dribble water onto the leaf and tilt the leaf so that that a few water droplets travel across it.) What is happening to the dirt? (The water has picked up the dirt and left the leaf itself clean.) What is happening to the water and the leaf? Lotus leaves, and other surfaces in nature, are what we call superhydrophobic. (Proceed to share with students additional information on superhydrophobic surfaces, including condensation and the Wenzel and Cassie Baxter wetting states, as found in the Lesson Background section, as is suitable for your students and time constraints.)
Why would this property be important for the lotus plant in nature?
How may this property relate to keeping clothes and other materials clean?
(Show students the following videos, which demonstrate examples of how clothing, cars and housing surfaces can remain clean by applying a superhydrophobic coating.)
Today, we will study superhydrophobic surfaces and their applications and limitations.

Lesson Background & Concepts for Teachers (Return to Contents)

Superhydrophobic Surfaces

Watercolor painting of  graceful flowers and leaves with many Chinese characters on one side.
When the lotus plant emerges on the surface of a pond or lake, it remains pristine despite its muddy environment. Flower Breaking the Surface, Palace Museum, Beijing, China. Painting by Yun Shouping, 17th century, Qing Dynasty.
In some Asian religions, the lotus plant is revered as a symbol of purity. The roots of the lotus plant take hold in the muddy bottoms of ponds and riverbeds. From there, thick stems rise above the water's surface and issue giant, pristine leaves and flowers. The leaves remain clean despite the water and mud on which they rest. Even water refuses to stick to the leaves of the lotus plant. Instead, it beads on the surface and rolls off at the slightest disturbance (see Figure 2).
Two images: (left) Photo shows nine round, flat lotus leaves floating on the water surface, looking dry on top, with silvery droplets scattered on them. (right) Two silvery beads rest on a bed of pointy bumps.
Figure 2. Leaves of Indian Lotus, Nelumbo nucifera, at Lotus Pond, Hyderabad, India. Water does not wet the lotus leaves, but instead forms beads of water that easily roll off its edges. In this computer-generated microscopic image of a lotus leaf with water droplets, notice the double structure of the leaf and the protrusions from the leaf covered in a rough, waxy material, which creates its superhydrophobic surface.
Scientists have found that the basis for both of these properties (self-cleaning and water-repellent) lies in the rough structure of the surface of the lotus leaves. The lotus leaf has a series of protrusions on the order of 10 μm (1.0 x 105 m) high covering its surface. Each protrusion is itself covered in bumps of a hydrophobic, waxy material that are roughly 100 nm (1 x 107 m) in height. When water droplets are applied to the lotus leaf, they sit lightly on the tips of the hydrophobic protrusions as if on a bed of nails (see Figure 2). This combined structure traps a layer of air in between the surface of the leaf and the water droplet. Hence, the water is not allowed to wet the surface and is easily displaced (see Figure 3).
(left) A four-part diagram shows side views of water droplets rolling off a normal surface (the water droplet is flattened on the side in contact with the surface) and a superhydrophobic surface (the water droplet bead sits above a bumpy surface). (right) Beaded water droplets sit intact on a screen-like grid surface.
Figure 3. (left) The unique roughness of superhydrophobic surface forces water droplets into spherical drops that minimize contact with the surface, rolling off easily and carrying away dirt and other debris, leaving the surface clean. (right) Water drops roll off a screen door treated with a superhydrophobic powder coating developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Even though the mesh is porous, water drops do not pass through due to the extreme water repellency of the powder coating.
The surface of a lotus leaf is an example of superhydrophobicity. On a superhydrophobic surface, the contact angle is greater than 150o, meaning almost no wetting of the surface by the liquid takes place. This leads to the second property associated with lotus plants — the ability to stay spotlessly clean. As rain falls on a superhydrophobic surface like the lotus leaf, the water droplets roll easily off the leaf surfaces (see Figure 3). As the droplets travel along the leaves, they pick up any dirt or other matter they encounter along the way. This process keeps the lotus leaves dry, clean and free of pathogens such as bacteria and fungi.
The self-cleaning and water-repellent qualities of superhydrophobic surfaces have the potential for many practical applications. House paints, roof tiles and various surface coatings are already on the market (see Figure 3). These products are examples of "biomimicry." By understanding how the lotus leaf and other plants create superhydrophobic surfaces by using a two-tiered surface layer, engineers have created human-made surfaces that "mimic" the properties of the natural ones. One of the most interesting uses of human-made superhydrophobic surfaces are fabrics made by Nano-Tex™ and other manufacturers that repel tomato sauce, coffee and even red wine. Researchers are also developing fabrics that can stay dry for days underwater, swimsuits that cannot become wet, and ship hulls with dramatically reduced drag.
Condensation and Sperhydrophobic Surfaces
In nature, when dew condenses on lotus leaves, the dew soon rolls off the leaf, just as water droplets falling onto the leaf do. However, when scientists began to study the superhydrophobic properties of the lotus leaf, they discovered water behaved differently in laboratories. Water poured or dropped on leaves in a controlled setting still demonstrated superhydrophobic properties. However, when water vapor was allowed to condense onto a lotus leaf in the lab, the water droplets were "sticky" and clung to the leaves.
A three-part side-view diagram shows a tiny water droplet positioned within a jagged surface; as it grows in size to above the rough surface, it is still anchored deep within the base of the textured surface.
Figure 4. The Wenzel wetting state. When water condenses on a rough surface, it condenses from within the texture and forms a droplet in the "sticky" Wenzel wetting state.
When water vapor condenses on a rough surface, it forms from inside the texture of the surface. As this water droplet grows it enters the "sticky" Wenzel wetting state in which the droplet is "pinned" to the surface (see Figure 4). These droplets do not display the easy motion of droplets on a superhydrophobic surface. In the lab, droplets remain in this "sticky" state, but in nature water vapor condensation, such as dew, soon transitions into a second wetting state known as the Cassie-Baxter wetting state.
Side-view diagrams show liquid droplets embedded within a rough solid surface (left, Wenzel state) and sitting atop the rough surface (right, Cassie-Baxter state).
Figure 5. Comparison of the Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter droplet wetting states. In the Wenzel state, the water droplet fills the spaces in the rough surface. In the Cassie-Baxter state, the water droplet sits on top of the rough surface with a layer of air underneath.
When water is dropped or poured onto superhydrophobic surfaces, the water droplets sit lightly on the very tips of the surface protrusions, leaving a layer of air between the droplets and the leaf surface. Water droplets in this Cassie-Baxter state demonstrate the extreme water repellency that characterize superhydrophobicity (see Figure 5).
The transition between the Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter states requires an input of energy. In nature, this energy might be provided by the mechanical energy supplied by wind or water movement. When dew forms on a lotus leaf in the "sticky" Wenzel state, the movement of the leaf provides enough energy to "unpin" the water droplet and allow it free movement to roll off the leaf. In a laboratory setting, this mechanical energy must be provided by the experimenter, such as placing the lotus leaf on a stereo speaker or shaking the lotus leaf by hand.

Associated Activities (Return to Contents)

  • Exploring the Lotus-Effect - Students explore and compare the superhydrophobic water-repellent and "self-cleaning" properties of the lotus leaf and cloth with a synthetic superhydrophobic coating. They observe the Wenzel and Cassie Baxter wetting states with condensation droplets on leaf surfaces. They consider the real-life engineering applications for these amazing properties.

Pre-Lesson Assessment

Opening Biomimicry Brainstorm: Show students the 24-second "Water on Lotus Leaf" video by Stratege2002, available at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFHcSrNRU5E. Afterwards, ask students, either individually or in small groups, to brainstorm to develop possible explanations for the phenomena. Require students to also propose how such an effect might be useful if you could mimic it. As a class, have students share their ideas and decide on a few of the best ideas.

Post-Introduction Assessment

Contrast Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter States: On a large note cards or pieces of paper, have students write the differences between the Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter wetting states. Draw a line down the center of the paper, write Wenzel on one side and Cassie-Baxter on the other, and then list the differences between the two states, side by side. Do this either individually, in small groups, or as a class using an overhead projector.

Lesson Summary Assessment

Three-Minute Writing: Hand each student a note card. Instruct them to write down — in three minutes — everything they learned in today's lesson. It doesn't matter if the information is out of order. Small diagrams or drawings are fine. Encourage students to try to fill the note card front and back in the time given. Require that they do this from memory — they may not refer to their notes.

Homework

Reading a Scientific Article: Either from a hard copy or online, have students read the Scientific American article, Self-Cleaning Materials: Lotus Leaf-Inspired Nanotechnology by Peter Forbes. Then have students answer the following questions:
  1. What are the causes and effects of superhydrophobicity (the lotus effect)?
  2. How might the lotus effect be used in consumer products?
  3. What is superwettability? What are its causes and effects?
  4. How might superwettability be used in consumer products?
  5. What did Andrew R. Parker find interesting about the Stenocara beetle? How is his design to imitate the beetle being used?

Boreyko, Jonathan B. and Chuan-Hua Chen. Published October 21, 2009. "Restoring Superhydrophobicity of Lotus Leaves with Vibration-Induced Dewetting." Physical Review Letters, Vol. 103, No. 17. Accessed July 2010. (abstract) http://prl.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v103/i17/e174502

de Gennes, Pierre-Gilles, et al. Capillarity and Wetting Phenomena: Drops, Bubbles, Pearls, Waves, Waves. New York, NY: Springer, 2004.

Forbes, Peter. "Self-Cleaning Materials: Lotus Leaf-Inspired Nanotechnology." Published July 30, 2008. Scientific American. Accessed July 2010. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=self-cleaning-materials

"Nature's Raincoats." Last updated 2009. The Royal Society: Summer Science Exhibition. Accessed September 1, 2010. http://www.naturesraincoats.com/

Zenner, Greta M., et al. "Lotus Leaf Effect." University of Wisconsin-Madison Materials Research, Science and Engineering Center (MRSEC) Interdisciplinary Education Group, Nanoscale Informal Science Education Network. Accessed July 2010. http://mrsec.wisc.edu/Edetc/EExpo/surfaces/NanoSurfaces_ProgramGuide.pdf

Contributors

Jean Stave, Durham Public Schools, North Carolina , Professor Chuan-Hua Chen, Mechanical Engineering and Material Science, Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University, acknowledgments: Jonathan Boreyko, Mechanical Engineering and Material Science, Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University

Copyright

© 2011 by Mechanical Engineering and Material Science, Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University
This digital library content was developed under an NSF CAREER Award (CBET- 08-46705) and an RET supplement (CBET-10-09869).

Supporting Program (Return to Contents)

NSF CAREER Award and RET Program, Mechanical Engineering and Material Science, Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University

Last Modified: April 18, 2014
K12 engineering curriculum K-12 engineering curricula K12 engineering curricula K-12 engineering activities K12 engineering activities K-12 engineering lessons K12 engineering lessons Engineering for children Engineering activities for children K-12 science activities K12 science activities K-12 science lessons K12 science lessons K12 engineering K-12 engineering K-12 engineering education K12 engineering education Are you a bot?
Use of the TeachEngineering digital library and this website constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.