Hands-on Activity: A Matter of Leaching

Contributed by: Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering and Applied Science, University of Colorado Boulder

Photo shows a hole in the ground filled with dirty, still water.
Dirty water.
copyright
Copyright © http://sgp.undp.org

Summary

Students leach organic matter from soil to create a water sample with high dissolved organic matter content (DOM), and then make filters to see if the DOM can be removed. They experience the difficulties of removing DOM from water, and learn about other processes that might make DOM removal more effective.
This engineering curriculum meets Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS).

Engineering Connection

Identifying safe and suitable drinking water sources is an important environmental engineering task to support communities. When identifying potential water sources, engineers always consider the amount of dissolved organic matter (DOM) that is present because DOM can be transformed into varopis dangerous chemicals when exposed to chlorine during the water treatment cleaning process. Before municipal water comes out of a faucet, it goes through several treatment steps to make sure it is safe for human consumption. Engineers design these water treatment processes and facilities.

Pre-Req Knowledge

A familiarity with dissolved organic matter and a general understanding of conventional drinking water treatment processes, as presented in the associated lesson, All About Water!

Learning Objectives

After this activity, students should be able to:

  • Explain the process of filtration and its value in treating water.
  • Describe the difficulty of removing dissolved organic matter content (DOMC) from water.

More Curriculum Like This

All About Water!

Students learn about the differences between types of water (surface and ground), as well as the differences between streams, rivers and lakes. Then, they learn about dissolved organic matter (DOM), and the role it plays in identifying drinking water sources.

Elementary Lesson
You Are What You Drink!

Students learn about the various methods developed by environmental engineers for treating drinking water in the United States.

Middle School Lesson
Natural and Urban "Stormwater" Water Cycles

Students examine in detail the water cycle components and phase transitions, and then learn how water moves through the human-made urban environment. Students show their understanding of the process by writing a description of the path of a water droplet through the urban water cycle, from the dropl...

Straining out the Dirt

Students groups build water filters using activated carbon, cotton and other materials to clean a "dirty" water sample made from chocolate powder added to tap water. They test and make observations of filter effectiveness, suggesting material and layering design improvements.

Middle School Activity

Educational Standards

Each TeachEngineering lesson or activity is correlated to one or more K-12 science, technology, engineering or math (STEM) educational standards.

All 100,000+ K-12 STEM standards covered in TeachEngineering are collected, maintained and packaged by the Achievement Standards Network (ASN), a project of D2L (www.achievementstandards.org).

In the ASN, standards are hierarchically structured: first by source; e.g., by state; within source by type; e.g., science or mathematics; within type by subtype, then by grade, etc.

  • Define a simple design problem reflecting a need or a want that includes specified criteria for success and constraints on materials, time, or cost. (Grades 3 - 5) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
  • Knowledge gained from other fields of study has a direct effect on the development of technological products and systems. (Grades 6 - 8) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
  • Develop, communicate, and justify a procedure to separate simple mixtures based on physical properties (Grade 5) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
  • Identify problems, and propose solutions related to water quality, circulation, and distribution – both locally and worldwide (Grade 6) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
Suggest an alignment not listed above

Materials List

Each group needs:

To share with the entire class:

  • sand (approximately 5-10 pounds)
  • gravel (approximately 5-10 pounds)
  • cotton balls
  • screening (one to two 4"x4" squares per group)
  • activated charcoal or carbon (optional, can be purchased on amazon.com or at some garden centers)
  • garden soil, not potting soil (one handful per group)
  • permanent marker

Introduction/Motivation

  • In this activity, we are going to act like environmental engineers, responsible for delivering clean drinking water to a community. But first, we will make water dirty!
  • To make dirty water, we are going to leach organic matter from soil. Does anyone know what a leech is? A leech is a bug that sucks blood, and just like a leech sucks blood, we are going to suck the organic matter from soil! We are leaching organic matter to simulate a natural stream or groundwater drinking source. All natural bodies of water have organic matter in them—it's just the amount that differs.
  • Our simulation will be helpful in showing the hardships of cleaning water that contains high organic matter content. You will each be given a plastic bag and will put soil and water in the bag and let it sit for several days. After the water is nice and dirty, you will design and build water filters and see how clean you can get the water!

Vocabulary/Definitions

filter: A porous material through which water can pass in order to strain out suspended solids.

filtration: The process of passing through a filter.

leach: Putting water through a sample to remove some constituents.

Procedure

Background

Students leach organic matter from soil and create water samples with high DOM content by soaking dirt in water. They design and build water filters by layering sand, gravel, cotton balls, screening, activated charcoal and/or soil inside the tops of two-liter bottles. After the water sits for three days, students test to see how effective their filters are at cleaning the dirty water. Then they rebuild their filters to make improvements, and reflect on their designs.

Before the Activity

  • Gather materials.
  • Cut the two-liter bottles in half.
  • Make copies of the attached A Matter of Leaching Worksheet, one per student.
  • Divide the class into groups of three or four students.

With the Students

Part 1: Leaching Organic Matter

  1. Distribute the worksheets.
  2. Give each group a zip-lock sandwich bag that contains a handful of soil. Have students write their names on their bags in permanent marker.
  3. Instruct students to make observations about their soil. Prompt students to notice texture, smell and color.
  4. Fill each bag with warm water until it is approximately three quarters full (see Figure 1).
  5. Let the bags sit with no disruption for a minimum of three days.

Bag of water with soil in the bottom. Water has turned a light brown color.
Figure 1. Leaching organic matter.
copyright
Copyright © 2012 Jessica Ebert, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder

Part 2: Filtering

  1. Hand bags back out to students (without shaking).
  2. Have students make new observations about the contents of their bags. Instruct students to write about their observations on their worksheets.
  3. Give each student a top half of a two-liter bottle. Pass out one coffee filter to each group, and have students insert the coffee filters into their two-liter bottles tops (see Figure 2).
  4. List the following materials on the board: sand, gravel, cotton balls, screening, activated charcoal or carbon, and soil. Tell students that their challenge is to work as engineers to make filter that effectively clean the water. They can use any of the materials listed on the board to put onto the coffee filter inside their two-liter bottles tops.
  5. Have students brainstorm and then sketch filter designs on their worksheets. Their sketches should show the various layers of materials they are going to use. Have students show their designs to the teacher and explain why they think their designs will work.
  6. Hand out materials and give students time to create their filters.
  7. After all groups have built their designs, begin testing the filters. Give two plastic cups to each group. Instruct each group to take their bag of dirty water and pour most of it into one of the plastic cups; hold back a bit of the dirty water as a control for final comparison).

Photo shows two red cups, one with an upside-down top half of a two liter bottle containing a coffee filter resting inside of it.
Figure 2. The filtering process.
copyright
Copyright © 2012 Jessica Ebert, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder

  1. Have students insert their two-liter bottles and coffee filters into the second, dry cup (see Figure 2). Then, instruct them to pour the dirty water from the first cup into the top of the two-liter bottle, their filter system. Note that, depending on the materials students choose to use for their filters, it might take a good deal of time for the water to exit the filter.
  2. Have students run the water through their filters three times, each time moving the filtering apparatus onto the empty cup and pouring the excess water on top of the filter.
  3. Expect students to be able to see a difference between their initial water samples and the final products. Prompt students to think about how well their filters worked. Would you drink this water?
  4. Have students redesign their filters based on what they've learned so far. Then, instruct them to filter their cleaner water with their improved filtering apparatus two times. Now, students have their final products.
  5. Have students make observations about their filtered water and write notes on their worksheets. Have students compare their before and after products.
  6. Compare final products between groups and prompt students to think about why some designs worked better than others. (Expect filters with the most sand and gravel to be the most effective. The longer it takes the water to flow through the filter, the cleaner it will be, due to the fact that the water had more contact time.)

Attachments

Troubleshooting Tips

  • Thoroughly wet the sand before making it available for filter building. If the sand is too dry, it absorbs the water instead of filtering it through.
  • The more sand in the design, the longer it takes to filter, so limit the amount of sand that students are permitted to use if testing time is limited.
  • Make sure the bags of soil and water are sealed tightly and stored in upright positions in order to prevent any spills and messes.
  • Do not let students drink their filtered water! Explain that even though the water may look clean, dissolved organic matter still exists in the water and it is not safe to drink. In a real water treatment process, the water would go through many more purification steps before it would be safe for consumption.

Assessment

Pre-Activity Assessment

In-Class Questions: Can anyone list the materials used in a drinking water treatment plant filter? (Answer: Sand, gravel and activated charcoal.) How do these materials compare to what we have in class today? (You may not have all the same materials, but you can ask students what they think each of the materials helps with.)

Activity Embedded Assessment

Questioning Designs: When students have finished their designs, have them discuss the pros and cons within their groups to decide on a final design. Circulate around the classroom to listen in on the discussions. When students present their final designs, have them explain their reasoning. Ask questions such as: Why did you decide to place the sand at the top (or other location) of your filter? Do you think that it was a good decision to omit gravel (or another material)? Why?

Worksheet: During the activity, have students complete their worksheets.

Post-Activity Assessment

Reflection: Have one student from each group bring its final water sample to the front of the room. Instruct students to rank water samples from cleanest to dirtiest (explain that they are just basing this off of visual observations, and that many of the solids have been removed from the water samples, but that does not mean the water is really "clean"). Have the groups ranked first and last explain their filter designs, describing how they were made and the order of the materials. Guide students talk about the differences in their filters and decide which materials worked best. Discuss why the dissolved organic matter was not removed very well. (Due to the lack of activated charcoal in the designs, no chemical reactions take place with the DOM. The DOM cannot be filtered out with the students' methods because the molecules are so small. However, they probably did a pretty good job of removing many of the suspended solids!)

Contributors

Jessica Ebert; Marissa H. Forbes

Copyright

© 2012 by Regents of the University of Colorado.

Supporting Program

Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering and Applied Science, University of Colorado Boulder

Acknowledgements

This digital library content was developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. DGE 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.

Last modified: June 6, 2017

Comments