SummaryDuring this engineering design/build project, students investigate many different solutions to a problem. Their design challenge is to find a way to get school t-shirts up into the stands during home sporting events. They follow the steps of the engineering design process to design and build a usable model, all while keeping costs under budget.
All types of engineers design products to satisfy some need to address some problem. To do this, engineers follow a design process to help them create the best possible product or solution. It is essential for all engineers to become comfortable with the steps of the process as well as particular project requirements and constraints (such as as a budget).
After this activity, students should be able to:
- List the steps of the engineering design process.
- Explain why engineering is driven by need.
- Work under the constraints of a budget.
- Explain how potential energy is converted to kinetic energy to launch a T-shirt.
Each TeachEngineering lesson or activity is correlated to one or more K-12 science,
technology, engineering or math (STEM) educational standards.
All 100,000+ K-12 STEM standards covered in TeachEngineering are collected, maintained and packaged by the Achievement Standards Network (ASN),
a project of D2L (www.achievementstandards.org).
In the ASN, standards are hierarchically structured: first by source; e.g., by state; within source by type; e.g., science or mathematics;
within type by subtype, then by grade, etc.
Each TeachEngineering lesson or activity is correlated to one or more K-12 science, technology, engineering or math (STEM) educational standards.
All 100,000+ K-12 STEM standards covered in TeachEngineering are collected, maintained and packaged by the Achievement Standards Network (ASN), a project of D2L (www.achievementstandards.org).
In the ASN, standards are hierarchically structured: first by source; e.g., by state; within source by type; e.g., science or mathematics; within type by subtype, then by grade, etc.
Design, build, and refine a device that works within given constraints to convert one form of energy into another form of energy.
(Grades 9 - 12 )
Do you agree with this alignment? Thanks for your feedback!This Performance Expectation focuses on the following Three Dimensional Learning aspects of NGSS:
Science & Engineering Practices Disciplinary Core Ideas Crosscutting Concepts Design, evaluate, and/or refine a solution to a complex real-world problem, based on scientific knowledge, student-generated sources of evidence, prioritized criteria, and tradeoff considerations.
Alignment agreement: Thanks for your feedback!
At the macroscopic scale, energy manifests itself in multiple ways, such as in motion, sound, light, and thermal energy.
Alignment agreement: Thanks for your feedback!Although energy cannot be destroyed, it can be converted to less useful forms—for example, to thermal energy in the surrounding environment.
Alignment agreement: Thanks for your feedback!Criteria and constraints also include satisfying any requirements set by society, such as taking issues of risk mitigation into account, and they should be quantified to the extent possible and stated in such a way that one can tell if a given design meets them.
Alignment agreement: Thanks for your feedback!
Energy cannot be created or destroyed—it only moves between one place and another place, between objects and/or fields, or between systems.
Alignment agreement: Thanks for your feedback!Modern civilization depends on major technological systems. Engineers continuously modify these technological systems by applying scientific knowledge and engineering design practices to increase benefits while decreasing costs and risks.
Alignment agreement: Thanks for your feedback!
Design and use a budget, including income (net takehome pay) and expenses (mortgage, car loans, and living expenses) to demonstrate how living within your means is essential for a secure financial future
Do you agree with this alignment? Thanks for your feedback!
For sketching and prototype-building, each group needs:
- paper, pencils and erasers
- assortment of office/classroom supplies and small arts and crafts supplies, such as paper, tape, scissors, glue, Popsicle sticks, paper clips, rubber bands, twist ties, etc.
For full-scale model building, groups may request and need:
- pieces of wood, such as cuts of plywood, dowel, 2 x 4 beams
- PVC pipes and joints
- nails, screws, hinges, springs
- elastic tubing
- bungee cords
- other items available at grocery, hardware and dollar/discount stores
Note: Activity costs will vary widely, depending on materials requested by/made available to students. A rough estimate is $10-15 per group. To keep costs low, try to use scraps, leftovers from home and recycling bin materials.
Each group needs:
- Budget Sheet
- Presentation Guidelines
- Presentation Peer Review, one per person x number of groups in the class
To share with the entire class:
- power drill
- drill bits, including a hole cutter (a circular saw drill bit attachment that cuts wider holes in wood sheets)
- duct tape
- wood glue
- screw drivers
- computer with Internet access (to show an eight-minute video)
Worksheets and Attachments
More Curriculum Like This
Students are challenged to find a way to get school t-shirts up into the stands during sporting events. They work with a real client (if possible, such as a cheerleading squad, booster club or band) to determine the requirements and constraints that would make the project a success, including a budg...
Students are introduced to the physics concepts of air resistance and launch angle as they apply to catapults. This includes the basic concepts of position, velocity and acceleration and their relationships to one another. They
Students learn about nondestructive testing, the use of the finite element method (systems of equations) and real-world impacts, and then conduct mini-activities to apply Maxwell’s equations, generate currents, create magnetic fields and solve a system of equations. They see the value of NDE and FEM...
Students are introduced to the engineering design process, focusing on the concept of brainstorming design alternatives. They learn that engineering is about designing creative ways to improve existing artifacts, technologies or processes, or developing new inventions that benefit society.
During home football (or basketball) games, your school's cheerleaders have decided they want to throw school t-shirts into the crowd during game breaks. The problem is they don't have any way to get the shirts up to the top rows from the field (or court). The cheerleading coach has approached your class to see if you can design and build some device to help them out.
All engineering designs start with a need. For example, practical solar panels were engineered when companies like NASA needed a way to power satellites in space. The Internet was born when the US military needed a way to communicate between computers. Here, cheerleaders need a way to get a t-shirt high into the bleachers. So now what do we do? As engineers, how do we actually go about designing something to meet our client's need?
When faced with a design challenge, engineers follow the engineering design process. This process consists of the following five basic steps (write them on the board, in a circle arrangement): 1) ask, 2) imagine, 3) plan, 4) create, and 5) improve.
The first step is to identify the need or problem to be solved by "asking" yourself or someone else what issues need help. Then you "imagine" as many different ways as possible to meet the need. Team brainstorming helps with this step. In step three, you choose the best idea and figure out how to design it by making a "plan." Then you "create" your design and because the first attempt is never perfect, step five is to "improve" on your design. Engineers typically follow this circular process as they design solutions to all kinds of challenges to make things better for people.
While all five steps are important, it is essential to emphasize the second and third steps: imagine and plan. During step 2, when you are imagining your design, it helps to work in teams and think "outside the box." This helps generate more creative designs.
(optional; This is a good time to show an inspiring eight-minute ABC News Nightline video called "The Deep Dive," which showcases an engineering design firm going through this creative step as they design a shopping cart. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M66ZU2PCIcM.)
Here's one example of how your "out of the box" creative thinking can benefit an engineering design. Alligator clips are little devices that temporarily connect two or more wires (show Figure 3). How do you think someone came up with the idea for alligator clips? Well, during step 2, when a team was brainstorming, one engineer said something about training mice to bite down on the wire ends to hold them together. Although the idea seemed a bit ridiculous at the time, it led to the development of alligator clips, which act like mice biting down on the ends of two wires!
As wild as some of the ideas may be from your imagining in step 2, your team must select the best idea in order to start step 3. During the planning stage, every design project has its own particular requirements and constraints to consider. But, almost all projects have a budget, which limits what can be spent for the project. It is important to make a detailed and well thought out plan with all the pricing accounted for before you start building. Let's get going!
If students are given a real client who plans to use the device, it greatly increases students' interest in the project and the quality of their designs. This client could be the cheerleading squad who will use the resulting working models during home sports games, or other students in the class who use their working model designs during an upcoming school pep rally. These arrangements take some extra time to set up but really make the project more meaningful and fun — a real-world project.
The design challenge itself is open ended, so designs could vary greatly, but given the constraints listed in #4 of the Procedure section, most "products" end up being some sort of catapult, slingshot or crossbow. Figure 1 shows two examples of the kinds of devices that might be designed. Limit the potential materials the students can request to basic supplies available at any hardware, grocery or dollar/discount store. Use or modify the attached Budget Sheet, which contains a fictional set of costs for the available materials, to present to students with their construction materials options. Remind students to plan ahead and keep their designs within the budget.
To complete this design challenge, give students twelve 50-minute class periods. To stay on schedule, require students to meet the interim deadlines and accomplishments suggested below.
Period 1: Introduce the project and the engineering design process. Begin brainstorming.
Period 2: Conduct the associated lesson, Physics of the Flying T-Shirt, and its two math worksheets.
Period 3: Continue brainstorming, this time with all the constraints in place.
Periods 4-5: Build a miniature prototype and draw a detailed sketch of the full-sized design.
Periods 6-10: Build the actual device. Have groups test and redesign their devices as time permits.
Periods 11-12: Final test for all groups. Project wrap up.
Before the Activity
- (optional) Arrange for a real-world "client" for the design challenge.
- Visit your local hardware (and/or grocery, dollar/discount) store to gather information on available materials and pricing. Personalize the Budget Sheet for your class project.
- Make copies of the Budget Sheet, Presentation Guidelines and Presentation Peer Review handouts.
- Prepare to show the class an eight-minute online video (see hot link in the Additional Multimedia Support section).
- Gather materials and tools to be used by the entire class.
With the Students
- Period 1: Introduce the students to their engineering design challenge — to design and build a device to meet the cheerleading squad's need. (allow 10 minutes)
- Divide the class into groups of three or four students each.
- Emphasize the importance of teamwork, thinking "outside the box," and the engineering design process as students prepare to start step 2: imagine. At this point, do not impose too many (or any) constraints. Instead, encourage wild ideas (for example: hiring a really strong man to throw the shirts up into the stands, or using a miniature helicopter to fly the shirts up into the upper bleachers). As time permits, show the eight-minute ABC Nightline "The Deep Dive" video (see hotlink in the Additional Multimedia Support section). (allow 40 minutes)
- Period 2: Conduct the associated Physics of the Flying T-Shirt lesson (and its two math worksheets) at this point. You want students to come to understand the importance of air resistance and launch angle and use this knowledge as they continue brainstorming during step 2 of the design process. For example, if students have not already thought about this, have them incorporate their understanding of air resistance to include fluid dynamic packaging of the t-shirts into their brainstorming session. (allow 50 minutes)
- Period 3: Make clear all project requirements and constraints. Requirements might include ease of use by three or fewer cheerleaders, reaching a certain distance with a certain level of accuracy, safety, reliability, and ease of repair. Constraints might include (but are not limited to) a $30 budget and no explosions. Have groups brainstorm some more and then narrow their ideas to what is feasible. Explain the types of energy that will be demonstrated in this project. Students that use a catapult, slingshot, or crossbow design will be converting elastic potential energy to kinetic energy. Or, perhaps a group will design a trebuchet or other device that relies on gravitational potential energy to be converted to kinetic energy. (allow 50 minutes)
- Periods 4-5: Have students start step 3 (plan) by picking their best idea and then quickly designing a miniature prototype using office and classroom supplies and small arts and crafts supplies. Require that the prototype be sized to be easily carried in one hand. Students will naturally move to step 4 (create) once they have their materials. These prototypes do not necessarily have to be working models; the idea is to create a visual and generate other issues before designing/creating their full-scale model. (allow 50 minutes)
- Periods 6-10: Once teams have finished prototype building, have them complete step 5 (improve) by analyzing their prototype and imagining what difficulties they might face when building the full-scaled model. This naturally leads (again) to steps 1-2-3 (ask-imagine-plan) as they design a full-sized device. Require that designs include a detailed drawing and a materials list to build it. At this point, check the designs to make sure they are feasible, and begin to compile a shopping list of materials for each group. (allow 50 minutes)
- Give each group their materials and start step 4 (create). Some groups may need to use basic power tools so spend some time showing the class how to safely use the available tools. Encourage teams to finish early so they have time to test their designs and make modifications. (allow 200 minutes)
- (optional) Have students create user's manuals for their devices.
- Periods 11-12: Hold a test day in which the entire class goes outside to test their devices. (allow 50 minutes)
- When all the building and testing is done, wrap up the project. Have groups present their devices to the class. Give each group a Presentation Guidelines handout that clarifies the presentation requirements. Also have students use the Presentation Peer Review to provide feedback for each presentation.
alligator clip: A device used to temporarily connect two wires. Made of toothed metal clips hinged near the back, making them look like alligator jaws. Also called crocodile clips.
brainstorming: A team creativity activity with the purpose to generate a large number of potential solutions to a design challenge.
constraint: A restriction on the degree of freedom one has in providing a solution to problem or challenge.
elastic potential energy: Mechanical energy stored within a material due to the distortion of its original shape.
engineering design process: A specific and iterative set of steps that engineers use to evaluate and refine potential solutions to problems or challenges. The five basic steps: 1) ask, 2) imagine, 3) plan, 4) create, and 5) improve.
gravitational potential energy: Energy that an object possesses due to its elevated position.
kinetic energy: Energy that an object possesses due to its motion.
model: A plan, representation (often in miniature) or description designed to show the main object or workings of a product concept.
prototype: A model of a product used for testing before it is manufactured. Prototypes help designers learn about the manufacturing process of a product, how people might use it, and its durability.
requirement: What a particular product or service should do. It is a statement that identifies a necessary attribute, capability, characteristic or quality. In engineering, sets of requirements are inputs into the design stages of product development inputs into the design stages of product development.
Class Discussion: Have the class think about new designs (inventions) they would create if they had the money and resources. Ask them about where their ideas came from, why people would want to use their designs, and how they would go about building their designs.
Activity Embedded Assessment
Project Review: Ask each group to evaluate their full-scale model designs, asking:
- Why did you choose that design?
- Will the client (cheerleaders) want to use your final product? Why?
- Will you be able to finish your device under budget?
Group Presentation: Have each group present their project to the class. Make sure they cover all the topics required in the Presentation Guidelines handout and use the Presentation Peer Review to provide feedback on other teams' presentations.
Power tools can be dangerous, so make sure students are shown how to operate them safely.
Open ended design projects can be difficult for students who have never worked on these types of projects before so don't feel discouraged if you have to help push them towards a certain design. Just being exposed to these types of projects is beneficial to many students.
Have students think about how they might further change/improve their designs if they scaled up to a manufacturing level of production with their best prototype.
Have students create user's manuals for their devices.
Additional Multimedia Support
IDEO is a worldwide engineering design and innovation consulting firm, known for digging deep and creatively to find unique solutions to design challenges. See more at https://www.ideo.com/. Show students an eight-minute ABC News Nightline show on IDEO's innovation process (see brainstorming around minute 4) as they redesign a shopping cart at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M66ZU2PCIcM
ContributorsJonathan MacNeil; Scott Duckworth; Brandi Jackson; Stephanie Rivale; Denise W. Carlson
Copyright© 2008 by Regents of the University of Colorado
Supporting ProgramIntegrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
The contents of this digital library curriculum were developed under grants from the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education (FIPSE), U.S. Department of Education and National Science Foundation (GK-12 grant no. DGE 0338326). However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the Department of Education or National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.
Last modified: January 12, 2019