Hands-on Activity: Concentrating on the Sun with PVs

Contributed by: Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering and Applied Science, University of Colorado Boulder

Four tilted rows of black panels mounted on the snowy ground under a blue sky with snowcapped mountains in the distance.
Many different factors affect the efficiency of solar panels — this lesson is about reflectance.
copyright
Copyright © NREL http://www.nrel.gov/data/pix/Jpegs/15548.jpg

Summary

Students design, build and test reflectors to measure the effect of solar reflectance on the efficiency of solar PV panels. They use a small PV panel, a multimeter, cardboard and foil to build and test their reflectors in preparation for a class competition. Then they graph and discuss their results with the class. Complete this activity as part of the Photovoltaic Efficiency unit and in conjunction with the Concentrated Solar Power lesson.
This engineering curriculum meets Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS).

Engineering Connection

Engineers design and build photovoltaic panels to maximize their efficiency. Engineers work in teams to design and test new ways of concentrating solar radiation onto PV panels and calculate the best way to install panels and reflectors so each PV panel produces the maximum amount of electricity possible.

Pre-Req Knowledge

Familiarity with the material covered in the associated lesson and curricular unit. Ability to read data from charts, and record and graph data on scatter plots.

Learning Objectives

After this activity, students should be able to:

  • Explain why concentrated PV systems can increase the output of photovoltaic panels.
  • Explain how certain angles between a photovoltaic panel and reflector increase or decrease the panel's power output.

More Curriculum Like This

Concentrated Solar Power

Students learn how the total solar irradiance hitting a photovoltaic (PV) panel can be increased through the use of a concentrating device, such as a reflector or lens.

High School Lesson
Solar Angles and Tracking Systems

Students learn about the daily and annual cycles of solar angles used in power calculations to maximize photovoltaic power generation. They gain an overview of solar tracking systems that improve PV panel efficiency by following the sun through the sky.

Let the Sun Shine!

Students learn how the sun can be used for energy. They learn about passive solar heating, lighting and cooking, and active solar engineering technologies (such as photovoltaic arrays and concentrating mirrors) that generate electricity.

Elementary Lesson
The Temperature Effect

Students explore how the efficiency of a solar photovoltaic (PV) panel is affected by the ambient temperature. They learn how engineers predict the power output of a PV panel at different temperatures and examine some real-world engineering applications used to control the temperature of PV panels.

High School Lesson

Educational Standards

Each TeachEngineering lesson or activity is correlated to one or more K-12 science, technology, engineering or math (STEM) educational standards.

All 100,000+ K-12 STEM standards covered in TeachEngineering are collected, maintained and packaged by the Achievement Standards Network (ASN), a project of D2L (www.achievementstandards.org).

In the ASN, standards are hierarchically structured: first by source; e.g., by state; within source by type; e.g., science or mathematics; within type by subtype, then by grade, etc.

  • Design a solution to a complex real-world problem by breaking it down into smaller, more manageable problems that can be solved through engineering. (Grades 9 - 12) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
  • Evaluate a solution to a complex real-world problem based on prioritized criteria and trade-offs that account for a range of constraints, including cost, safety, reliability, and aesthetics, as well as possible social, cultural, and environmental impacts. (Grades 9 - 12) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
  • Use appropriate measurements, equations and graphs to gather, analyze, and interpret data on the quantity of energy in a system or an object (Grades 9 - 12) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
  • Evaluate the energy conversion efficiency of a variety of energy transformations (Grades 9 - 12) Details... View more aligned curriculum... Do you agree with this alignment?
Suggest an alignment not listed above

Materials List

Each group needs:

  • mini PV panel ($10-30; available online; do a product search for "small solar panel" or see the Solar Panel Source Information attachment in the Photovoltaic Efficiency unit)
  • alligator clips
  • wires
  • multimeter ($10; available online; see the Solar Multimeter Source Information attachment in the Photovoltaic Efficiency unit) (experiment can be run with either one or two multimeters per group, see Procedure section for details)
  • cardboard, a 2 ft x 2 ft (.6 m x .6 m) piece
  • scissors
  • protractor (or use attached Protractor Printout, two per sheet, print out and cut apart)
  • aluminum foil
  • Investigation Worksheet, one per person
  • (if not using the sun as light source) clamp or desk lamp with 100W incandescent bulb (~$8; best for each group to have their own, but teams can share if necessary)

To share with the entire class:

  • duct or masking tape
  • paper and pencils, for drawing and sharing design ideas

Note: The non-expendable items (mini PV panels, multimeters, wires with alligator clamps, lamp and light bulb) are reusable for the entire four-lesson unit, as well as other projects.

Introduction/Motivation

Throughout this unit, we have learned about the importance of maximizing the efficiency of photovoltaic panels and different ways engineers maximize power output. Today, we're going to design, build and test small planar reflectors, and examine how reflecting and concentrating light onto a PV panel can help increase its power output. PV panels are expensive, so it is important to maximize the amount of power each individual panel produces. We can do this by increasing the amount of solar radiation that hits the panel.

Engineers rarely make the best designs on their first try. In this design project, your team will test your designs many times to see if you can find a way to make your design a little better each time. But, you cannot test forever; so as in all engineering projects, you have a time constraint, and when that time is up, your design will be tested as it is.

Each group has access to all the materials and tools needed to test their designs. Make sure to test different aspects of the designs individually before creating a final reflector design. For example, you may want to test different reflector angles, or test what happens if the foil is more or less crinkled. You may want to experiment with different reflector shapes, or see what happens if you curve them. You are completely free to be creative with your designs, as long as you stay within the material and time constraints. In the end, you want to have the design that creates the highest increase in the current output of the PV panel.

For the final design competition, we will use the same light, same panel and same placement for all reflector designs. This means that you must design your reflector systems so that they are not attached to a specific PV panel, but are free standing. Your designs also must let the PV panel lie flat on the ground; do not create a design that lifts the panel in any way.

During the competition, apply your new knowledge of solar reflecting techniques by guessing the current output of each panel and reflector system before it is tested. After a group presents their design, guess the current output you think it will create, and record this value on your worksheet. Your goal is to have the most accurate estimates, showing that you are now an engineer who understands the basics of how solar concentration systems work.

Vocabulary/Definitions

concentrated photovoltaic system: (CPV) A system designed to concentrate sunlight onto a PV panel or series of panels in order to increase their power output.

design iteration: An improvement in the design due to testing and redesigning.

irradiance: Power per unit area of solar energy hitting a surface.

planar reflector: A reflective panel used to reflect sunlight in order to increase the power output of a photovoltaic panel.

Procedure

Background

It is important to test the lamps, multimeters and solar panel devices before attempting to conduct the final design competition. The multimeters have many different settings that should be understood; this information can easily be found online or in the multimeter manual. For this experiment, DC current is measured. The exact current setting to use depends on the power of the light, efficiency of the panels, and distance between the panel and light. You want the setting that gives the most accuracy in measurement for comparing the reflector designs.

It is also important to measure the current output of the panel before each reflector design is tested. The current is sensitive to the light intensity, which may change slightly over time as the light warms up, or be affected by light through windows. The intensity can easily be disturbed by moving the panel, so it is important to try to minimize this throughout the competition by taping the panel to the floor or outlining exactly where it should be placed.

Diagram with arrows pointing from brainstorm to design to analyze, to build, to test and back to brainstorm.
The basic steps of the engineering design process.
copyright
Copyright © 2008 Denise W. Carlson, ITL Program, College of Engineering, University of Colorado at Boulder

When conducting the competition, it is helpful to gather all the students around the area where the panels are being tested so they can clearly see the designs. Placing the panel on the floor and clamping the lamp directly above it on a desk is one potential set-up (see Figure 2), but it is important to make sure that students do not bump or move items during the experiment. Having each group give a short presentation on their design before testing is a great way for them to give other students insight into their design, and allowing audience questions stimulates interaction among all students.

To find solutions to real-world problems, engineers follow the steps of the engineering design process. The primary steps include: brainstorm, design, analyze, build, test, and back to brainstorm, for as many iterations as needed. See more about the engineering design process at https://www.teachengineering.org/engrdesignprocess.php

Before the Activity

  • Gather materials.
  • Make copies of the Investigation Worksheets.
  • Test the panels and multimeters to make sure all items are working properly.
  • (Do this in advance or while students are creating/testing their designs.) Set up a final competition testing area. Place a lamp on a desk about one meter above the floor. Use tape to mark off an area that students are not permitted to cross so that the lamp is not moved during the final testing (see Figure 2). Also mark an area where the panel is to be placed.

With the Students

  1. As necessary, review the associated lesson concepts to make sure students understand the theory behind this activity.
  2. Conduct the Introduction/Motivation section with the students.
  3. Give the students an opportunity to ask any questions they may have on the process for the activity and competition.
  4. Divide the class into groups of two students each.
  5. Review the main steps of the engineering design process: brainstorm, design, analyze, build, test and re-design to improve. Then discuss the project constraints and requirements (real-world engineering design projects have constraints and requirements):
  • Set a project time limit.
  • Limit the amount and size of materials.
  • Aluminum foil must be wrapped on the cardboard; it cannot be used separately. The purpose of the foil is to provide a reflective surface for the sturdy cardboard.
  • During the final test, the reflector must stand up on its own without a student holding it.
  1. Have teams brainstorm and draw design ideas.
  2. Have the groups make plans for testing a few aspects of their designs. (Test only one variable at a time.)
  3. Give groups time to gather materials and tools for testing.
  4. Have the students gather the allotted materials and begin designing and experimenting with their designs. (Guide students in applying steps of the engineering design process. Are they brainstorming as a team, creating viable designs, testing them, and improving them? Make sure students understand that a design can be tested and then changed in big or small ways and this is called design iteration.) Figure 1 shows an example set-up to test how the angle of a simple planar reflector system affects the current output of the solar panel. Students can also bend and change other aspects of the reflector to find the design they believe will work the best.
    Photo shows a small photovoltaic panel with reflector panel made of foil-wrapped cardboard, hooked with wires to a multimeter.
    Figure 1. Example student practice test of a simple planar PV reflector system.
    copyright
    Copyright © 2008 Abigail Watrous, ITL Program, College of Engineering. University of Colorado at Boulder
  5. Keep students on task to meet the deadline for completing their final reflector designs.
  6. Make sure the final competition testing area is set up, as described in the Before the Activity section (see Figure 2).
    Photo shows students gathered outside a taped off floor area, ~ 1 x 1 meter in size, inside which a lamp is clamped on a desk ~.6 meters above the floor, facing down on a solar panel and foil contraption on the floor.
    Figure 2. Example a solar reflector design final competition testing area.
    copyright
    Copyright © Janet Yowell, ITL Program, College of Engineering. University of Colorado at Boulder
  7. Bring the students together and review the process for conducting the final design (see the Introduction/Motivation section for some description).
  8. Hand out the worksheets for the students to record data from the experiments and make their current output estimate for each group.
  9. Have the first team present. Have each group give a short presentation on their design before testing, and answer a few questions posed by other students.
  10. Measure the current output of the panel. Then turn off the lamp.
  11. Tell the students: "Apply your new knowledge of solar reflecting techniques by guessing the current output of each panel and reflector system before it is tested. After a group presents their design, guess the current output you think it will create, and record this value on your worksheet. Your goal is to have the most accurate estimates, showing that you are now an engineer who understands the basics of how solar concentration systems work." Give students time to record data on the panel and make their current estimate.
  12. Have a few students share their estimates with the entire class. (This helps keep students interested and engaged.)
  13. Place the reflector over the PV panel and turn on the lamp. (Drum roll is optional.)
  14. Have students record the current output on their worksheets.
  15. Repeat steps 14 through 19 for all groups. Make sure students do not bump or move items during the competition.
  16. Have the students complete the calculations on their worksheets.
  17. Discuss the results of the competition as a class and ask the students to describe what they have learned from this activity.

Attachments

Safety Issues

Encourage students to be gentle and careful with the solar panels and equipment.

Be aware that the lamps can become very hot when on.

Troubleshooting Tips

If you go outside, adjust the multimeters to a higher current setting to account for the brightness of the sun. (The 10A setting may require adjusting the position of the positive lead.) If you remain inside, use incandescent lamps for this activity, not CFLs.

Investigating Questions

  • What is the best angle to place reflectors?
  • What other factors do you think affect the ability of a reflector to improve the current output of a panel?
  • How do you think the current output would be affected if your reflector system were used on a stationary panel on a roof as the sun changes position in the sky?

Assessment

Pre-Activity Assessment

Think, Write, Swap: Assess student comprehension by having each student individually write his/her answers to the following questions:

  • Why would an engineer design, build and test a concentrating PV system?
  • What is a planar photovoltaic reflector?
  • What sort of materials would be the best for designing a reflector?

Have students swap papers with another student and discuss whether their answers are similar or different. Then ask several students to share their answers with the class.

Activity Embedded Assessment

Process Explanation: Talk with each group as they work on their experiment set-ups to be sure they understand the concepts and are correctly recording data. Let teams who have their experiments set up correctly visit and help other groups with their set-ups.

Post-Activity Assessment

Group Presentations: Have each group present their experimental results and final designs in a brief presentation to the class before the final competition testing.

Activity Extensions

Promote functionality and creativity. If time permits, have students create a commercial or marketing strategy for their concentrator in which the engineering and aesthetic features are highlighted.

Activity Scaling

  • For lower grades, conduct this activity as a class demonstration, and/or instead of using the multimeter, use small buzzers that change volume with changing current. This way, rather than filling out the worksheet with measurements, students can observe how the loudness of the buzzer increases or decreases as the angle between the solar panel and the reflector is changed or as a reflector is added to the panel. Buzzers are inexpensive ($4) and can be found at electronics and hardware stores such as RadioShack or online at http://www.scientificsonline.com/.
  • For upper grades, require more in-depth presentations and explanations of the purpose and theory behind reflectors.

Additional Multimedia Support

For a description of the engineering design process, see https://www.teachengineering.org/engrdesignprocess.php

Contributors

William Surles, Abigail Watrous, Malinda Schaefer Zarske, Jack Baum, Stephen Johnson (This high school curriculum was originally created as a class project by engineering students in a Building Systems Program course at CU-Boulder.)

Copyright

© 2009 by Regents of the University of Colorado.

Supporting Program

Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, College of Engineering and Applied Science, University of Colorado Boulder

Acknowledgements

The contents of these digital library curricula were developed by the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program under National Science Foundation GK-12 grant no. 0338326. However, these contents do not necessarily represent the policies of the National Science Foundation, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.

Last modified: August 10, 2017

Comments